Red Wing Nature Notes

September 19, 2009

Feral Pigs or Badgers?

Filed under: John's Posts, Phenology, all posts
John Tittle
John Tittle @ 11:52 am

There is an intense debate going on. I should make it clear this debate is taking place exclusively in my head. The experts agree that feral pigs have moved in and are laying waste to certain areas. “laying waste” is my description in this case. The reason I have more than a passing interest in this is that one of the areas affected is the field outside my house.

In areas near Frontenac State park and in our fields something has been expending a considerable amount of energy turning over sod. Bare dirt is exposed in large areas. If I had stumbled upon one of these scenes of destruction just walking I would be at a total loss as to the cause. If presented with the idea that a herd of pigs came during the night to do the destruction I would raise my eyebrows and accept it as one of those strange things that happens in this world.

A google search for “feral pigs minnesota” or the same search for Wisconsin area shows that there are wild pigs in Wisconsin and even some sightings in Minnesota. The wisconsin DNR has a map showing that feral pigs live in Pierce County just across the Mississippi river from us. A person who I’ve been told knows about trapping and tracking animals has observed the damage in Frontenac and in our fields and he is certain it is the work of pigs.

Why would I be a non believer?  The damage started a few weeks ago while I was mowing CRP land with a brushog pulled behind a tractor. When I was mowing I noted large soft areas in the fields filled with rodents that would scatter into the grass when the tractor wheels sunk into them. Also this year I have noted many badger holes in the fields. It takes several days to mow the fields. When I resumed mowing one morning I came upon an area that had been filled with rodents the night before. The ground was bare, the sod torn out in patches about a foot square in an area that covered 200 square feet. A short distance away was a fresh badger hole. As the mowing continued over the next couple of days there was more torn up ground. I was so impressed I asked a couple friends who get outside alot over to take a look. Neither had seen anything like this before. A couple of days later I got a call from one of them who said he’d been over near Frontenac State Park and seen the same kind of damage there. This is how I was put in touch with the trapper guy.

When he told me it was pigs I had already formed an opinion. I’ve had a hard time changing. Maybe because it’s because I don’t want pigs. So even though the experts say “Pig” I am clinging to “Badger”.
For the time being the massive destruction has stopped. The pig theory is that the pigs are eating acorns now and have left the fields alone.

Last night I looked for pig rubs and trails in the woods surrounding the fields. I went to two possible water sources in the area to look for pig wallows and found a few deer tracks. I went in the nearby woods where there are mature oaks and jumped two whitetails feasting on acorns. I stood and listened to the squirrels chatter and heard acorns fall around me when the wind blew. I saw deer tracks and little holes made by squirrels. The most apparant thing out of place was how dry everthing was.  No pig sign – that I could identify.

This morning I walked in the fields, not as if I was out for a walk, but more like somone looking for a lost watch. I found little holes in the grass like a skunk would make. There was a trail in the dew and followed it to more holes that were bigger, then there was one piece of sod that probably weighed as much as a skunk torn from the ground, then more little holes. This pattern repeats itself all over in the fields, less noticable than the dramatic destruction.  

video:  Maybe badger/Maybe pig

Before we had pigs on the radar the following badger theory was offered up. Right now everything is very dry and our clay soil is as hard as a rock. Voles seem to be living between the sod and the soil. They would be an easy target for a badger with big digging claws. It would be easier for a badger to scrape the sod off to get abundant voles than it would be to pursue pocket gophers in the hard clay. The unusual destruction would then be the result of dry weather and abundant vole populations.

 

Here are some questions I have of anyone who knows about feral pigs.
1. How can an animal that weighs over 100 lbs, doesn’t hibernate, doesent hunt, doesn’t store food sustain itself in Minnesota winter?
2. How can pigs move into an area, do all of this damage without leaving tracks or droppings?*
3. How come no one has seen a pig?
4. Why is there no sign of wallowing in the only two water sources for miles around?
I realize it is likely the experts are right, but I will still hope the badger theory is correct. Here is a video showing some of the evidence.

video: ferral pig or badger?

 *There are lots of droppings, but I think they have been identified as badger.

8 Comments »

  1. Thanks for investigating, John! I don’t mind the badgers, but if we have pigs, they have to go. Your badger evidence is very convincing, but a bit of doubt remains. Time for some game cameras?

    Comment by Jim — September 20, 2009 @ 9:20 am

  2. It has come to my attention that the Rochester Post-Bulletin will have a feature story in their Monday, September 28th edition covering feral pigs in the Frontenac area. It will be interesting to see if that article is based upon speculation or actual photographs. Stay tuned.

    Comment by Bruce — September 25, 2009 @ 7:00 am

  3. Ironically, just last month I heard a fellow bowhunter talking about taking some feral pigs while deer hunting in Southern WI near the Blue River Unit – Lower WI Riverway. That’s only 3hrs south from the Frontenac area, based on your findings, there is a high probability the damages are done by feral pigs. Here’s an article by MPR (http://news.minnesota.publicradio.org/features/2005/10/26_kelleherb_feralpigs/
    )
    published in 2005 which mentioned feral pigs thriving in Superior, WI. If they can survive in the Duluth and Superior, WI area, I don’t foreseen feral pigs having any problems surviving the winters in Frontenac.
    I am a avid bowhunter with resources to several bowhunter clubs and MN Deer Hunter Association, I’m sure professional bowhunters would be thrill to help you tame them into the freezer for the coming Holidays. :) Keep us updated. I’d like to know what your trapper finds out vs the DNR.

    Comment by Lee — September 29, 2009 @ 12:53 am

  4. Thanks for the comment Lee. Regarding pigs surviving winter. I know pigs have been seen around Minnesota and Wisconsin, but from what I have read they are not breeding populations. Seems they are escaped from game farms or regular pig farms or released on purpose.
    White tails are tough animals and they already eat everything in sight during winter. I would bet if pigs moved in to the area one or the other would starve.
    Now that it’s bow season maybe someone will see a pig and report it.


    John Tittle
    Comment by John Tittle — September 30, 2009 @ 11:58 pm

  5. pigs do survive winters and do breed in WI. There are established breeding populations in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan and Manitoba, both of which have more snow and are often colder than us. If pigs are released or travel to MN, they will reproduce and will have no problem with our winters. They eat roadkill, and any other dead things they find. The damage they cause is substainal. In TX, they cause over $50 million in agricultural damagae annually. Shooting them is also not the answer. It often causes them to disperse and become nocturnal. Successful removal operations often involve trapping followed by dogs… many states have outlawed shooting pigs because of this.

    Comment by ab — October 19, 2009 @ 3:37 pm

  6. ab- I’ve been learning a lot about pigs lately and I have no doubt we don’t want them around here. The “better to be safe than sorry” approach is good. From what I understand the trail cams the state has put on the land near us and in Frontenac haven’t yeilded anything yet. Even so I heard plans are moving ahead to put out corral traps.
    With all of the hunters out you’d think someone would see a pig if they are out there. I have never imagined that pigs eat roadkill. In that case, maybe they would occasionally end up as roadkill themselves. One more thing to watch for.


    John Tittle
    Comment by John Tittle — October 23, 2009 @ 5:48 am

  7. I thought your video was very good. I would agree from what you showed that it is more likely badgers than pigs. Most people would not tell the differance in the tracks as they are so similar, pigs being “rounder” than deer. The water hole would most likely have been tore up if pigs were in the area, also. They say the river at lake Pepin was frozen hard enough to walk on for several weeks in 2008-09 and that is why there may be pigs in the area now, but I have not heard of any seen or shot during the deer season yet. Hope you don’t have any more trouble in your area, but I would be more than happy to help clean out the pigs you find any.

    Comment by Kevin Anderson — February 18, 2010 @ 12:03 am

  8. last saturday i was fishing a small creek out side preston in filmore county. there i came accross a heavely damaged corn field the corn was trampled flat
    and all the corn cobs where eaten.i was puzzuled for a while but then thought maybe pig, looked it up and found photos of what pigs do to corn and i hate to say it but it apiers to have been pigs to.

    Comment by Shaun hicks — August 11, 2010 @ 7:50 am

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

Powered by WordPress